Three guiding questions, four stages
Each question opens a paragraph and moves the story a step, and each step needs a reason. From a model profile of an operations candidate:
- First impression: “What makes a candidate memorable?” “The panel’s gut feeling had initially favoured another job-seeker, whose answers sounded more confident.”
- Contrary evidence: “Why did that answer matter?” Give something observable: a routine, a test result.
- Decision: “What happened next?” “She got the job.”
- Later result: a time marker and a consequence. “Three months later, her team adopted the same one-question review.”
Words that separate impressions from evidence
A change of view convinces only when its cause is visible. Use the past perfect for earlier background: “The company had recently lost two coordinators.”
- Impressions: seemed, sounded, appeared. “His answers sounded more confident.”
- Evidence: showed, revealed, demonstrated. “Her concrete routine showed how she separated emotion from evidence.”
- Gut feeling: an instinctive reaction before reasoning, never proof on its own.
- Foolproof: designed not to fail. “The supposedly foolproof scoring sheet failed when two criteria contradicted each other.”
- Connectors: however, as a result, three months later.
Direct questions: five patterns
English puts an auxiliary before the subject, with one exception:
- Be, have or a modal first: “Why has the launch been delayed, and when can the supplier restart?”
- Do, does or did when there is no other auxiliary: “What does the role involve, and why did the previous coordinator leave?”
- No do or did when who or what is the subject: “Who approved the emergency budget?” Compare “Who did you call?” (who is the object).
- Negative questions check an expectation: “Didn’t the agency send the revised figures yesterday?”
- The preposition goes at the end: “Which department are you applying to?”
Indirect questions: statement word order
After a polite opening, use statement order and drop do, does or did. Yes/no questions need if or whether.
- “Could you tell me when the second interview starts?” (not “when does the second interview start”)
- “Do you know whether the panel has reached a decision?”
- “Would you mind telling me why the position became vacant?” Careful and formal, for sensitive topics.
- After I wonder or I’d like to know, end with a full stop: “I wonder why the timetable changed.”
A demanding question and its follow-up
Two colleagues test an interview question before using it. Listen: why could the Monday meeting be dropped, and what safeguard does the follow-up add?
Note the final would in “more than a puzzle … would”: it replaces “would tell me”.
Owen If you had to remove one meeting from our week, which would you choose?
Maya The Monday status meeting. Its point is to uncover risks, but the dashboard already shows them.
Owen How would you stop quieter colleagues from losing their chance to raise a concern?
Maya I would give colleagues fifteen minutes to write down risks and ask the project lead to respond publicly by noon.
Owen That answer tells me more than a puzzle about imaginary animals would.
Maya Exactly. A demanding question should reveal judgment and consequences, not just reward confidence.
Questions to discuss
Answer aloud with a reason and an example:
- “Should managers be allowed to hire mainly on gut feeling?”
- “Do interviews unfairly favour confident, fluent speakers?”
- “Which interview question would you most dread, and why?”
Common mistakes
Check your draft for these:
- “Could you tell me where is the office?” Say “where the office is”.
- “Who did approve the budget?” Drop did: “Who approved the budget?”
- “I wonder why did the timetable change?” Say “I wonder why the timetable changed.”
- A change of view with no cause: “At first the panel doubted her, but then they liked her.” Name the evidence.
- “She was amazing.” Show what the panel saw instead.
A 10-minute daily routine
Invent a candidate from your field; write the full profile at the weekend.
- 3 minutes: turn five work questions into indirect ones with different openings.
- 3 minutes: ask about one event both ways: “Who called the client?” / “Who did the client call?”
- 2 minutes: plan three guiding questions, one line per stage.
- 2 minutes: write the evidence sentence with showed or revealed.
What comes next
Next at B2: reply to health news by email, expand a 50-word draft into a story, and write a balanced post about adventure courses. At C1, prove your achievements with evidence in a covering email.
